List of Topics

SfC Home > Physics > Gravitation >

 

Feedback Comments on Gravitation

by Ron Kurtus

A total of 64 comments and questions have been sent in on Gravitation. They are listed according to date.

You can read them to further your understanding of the subject.



List of next 10 letters

Topic

Title

Country

Gravitation Gravitation on huge planet USA
 
Gravitation Relation between wormholes and gravitation India
 
Gravitation What is the origin of gravitation? India
 
Gravitation Energy from a gravity wheel Ireland
 
Gravitation Importance of time in a Black Hole India
 
Gravitation Interested in graviton theory USA
 
Gravitation How large does a star have to be to become a black hole? USA
 
Gravitation Relationship between dark matter and graviation? USA
 
Gravitation Who determined gravitation equation? UK
 
Gravitation Does dark matter cause people to be negative? RSA
 

Next 10

 




First 10 letters


Gravitation on huge planet

Topic: Gravitation

Question

December 7, 2010

I was wondering if you could send me some equations for measuring the force of gravity that is possessed by an object of particular size. The reason being I had a dream where I saw a planet that was 1000 times bigger than our galaxy and I know that a planet that size isn't possible, but if it were, I wanted to know the force of its gravitational attraction, what a 50 kilogram person would weigh on it, and its escape velocity, and I don't remember the equations to calculate those. Could you please label what each variable in those equations are? I'm sort of new to physics.

Dylan - USA

20810

Answer

The radius of the Milky Way galaxy is about 50,000 light years. That is about 5*10^20 m. Your planet would have the radius of 5*10^23 m (5 followed by 23 zeros).

The mass of the galaxy is 1.4*10^42 kg. However, it is not solid and has much empty space in it. However, if your planet was solid, it would collapse on itself and become a Black Hole.

Suppose the planet had 10^15 times the mass of the Milky Way = 1.4*10^57 kg.

Now F = GMm/R^2. If the person had a mass to 50 kg, the multiplication factor would be GM/R^2 =

(6.67*10^-11)(1.4*10^57)/(5*10^23)(5*10^23)= 0.37

In other words, the person would weigh about 1/3 of the weight on Earth. The reason is that even at 10^15 times the mass of the galaxy, the density is so small and the matter is so spread out that the weigh is not at great as you would expect.

This gives you an idea how to calculate things. For escape velocity, see:
http://www.school-for-champions.com/science/gravitation_escape_velocity.htm

Back to top


Relation between wormholes and gravitation

Topic: Gravitation

Question

November 2, 2010

Is there any relation between wormhole or time travel with gravitation.and what are these ?

vijit - India

20614

Answer

Time-travel and wormholes are considered possible in some physics and astronomical theories.

The General Theory of Relativity view of gravitation relates it to a curvature in space-time. This theory also allows the existence of wormholes, but they have never been experienced.

Back to top


What is the origin of gravitation?

Topic: Gravitation

Question

October 31, 2010

Q origin of gravitation?

vijit - India

20605

Answer

Gravitation is one of several properties of matter.

Back to top


Energy from a gravity wheel

Topic: Gravitation

Question

June 20, 2010

subject energy from gravity wheel
A big wheel 40 ft. high= to 60 ft. half circle has 4 half ton weights constantlt grip on the down side all the time for 1 minute
what speed will it reach, and what energy or power if concected to a generator could it produce
thanking you for allowing me to ask

- Ireland

19935

Answer

There is a lot of information missing, in order to draw any conclusions.

If the wheel is rolling down an incline, you need to know its coefficient of rolling friction, as well as the angle of the incline to determine its speed and power it will generate.

Also, an electrical generator requires a force to turn its rotors, depending on its size and configuration of its magnets.

Back to top


Importance of time in a Black Hole

Topic: Gravitation

Question

June 15, 2010

in black hole concept what is importance of time

sam - India

19908

Answer

A Black Hole is an object that has such high gravitation that light cannot escape. According to the Theory of Relativity, in extreme conditions like this, space is greatly distorted, as is time.

Of course, it is impossible to prove that time is distorted in a black hole, because there is no real way to measure it.

Back to top


Interested in graviton theory

Topic: Gravitation

Question

June 10, 2010

"Recently it has been pointed out that the characteristic quantum-gravity scale could be as low as the weak scale in theories with gravity propagating in higher dimensions. The observed smallness of Newton's constant is a consequence of the large compactified volume of the extra dimensions. We investigate the consequences of this supposition for high-energy collider experiments. We do this by first compactifying the higher dimensional theory and constructing a 3+1-dimensional low-energy effective field theory of the graviton Kaluza-Klein excitations and their interactions with ordinary matter. We then consider graviton production processes, and select photon plus missing energy and jet plus missing energy signatures for careful study. We find that both a 1 TeV e+e- collider and the CERN LHC will be able to reliably and perturbatively probe the fundamental gravity scale up to several TeV, with the precise value depending on the number of extra dimensions. Similarly, searches at LEP2 and the Tevatron are able to probe this scale up to approximately 1 TeV. We also discuss virtual graviton exchange, which induces local dimension-eight operators associated with the square of the energy-momentum tensor. We estimate the size of such operators and study their effects on two fermions to two photons observables." Gian F. Giudice, Riccardo Rattazzi, James D. Wells
Journal reference: Nucl.Phys. B544 (1999) 3-38
DOI: 10.1016/S0550-3213(99)00044-9
Cite as: arXiv:hep-ph/9811291v2

A few questions on this:
1. The graviton theory represents gravity as a particle, a particle has mass. Thus wouldn't gravity then act upon itself? Any detection of a graviton and its propagation would hide the base field acting on the graviton itself. With the graviton propagating in at least 8 dimensions would the gravitational affect of those 8 dimensions create a graviton in any remaining dimensions giving rise to quantum gravitons?
2. Quantum is a 'state' that is undetermined until it is observed. Does a 'quantum particle' exhibit gravity? How do you know? Once you observe the gravity are you not also observing the particle making it no longer "quantum"?
3. Is there an established base value of gravitational length like "Planck Length"? What is that value called and how is it conceived?
4. Will the detectors in the LHC be able to detect initial gravitational lengths?
5. What is low scale quantum gravity and what is the factors that define the TeV scale?

Thank You.

tom - USA

19875

Answer

Particles such as the graviton and photon have zero REST mass, as opposed to a particle like a proton, which has a specific mass when at or near zero velocity.

Although a photon has zero rest mass, light does exhibit momentum and can apply a force, such as seen in solar sails. I don't know about the graviton, although a similar principle may apply. However, while solar pressure can push on object, gravitation is a pulling force. The explanation of gravitation, using a graviton involves some sort of exchange of particles.

Quantum is not a state. Rather, particles can be in various quantum states.

String theory and a few other theories mathematically consider multiple dimensions. However, just because something is mathematically correct does not mean that it truly exists in the physical world. These theories can neither be proven or disproven.

The article you provided it is interesting, but it is beyond the scope of our material.

Back to top


How large does a star have to be to become a black hole?

Topic: Gravitation

Question

May 27, 2010

How large does a star have to be to become a black hole? is it possible for anything to escape a black hole? What would the mass of an object have to be to escape a black hole?

- USA

19801

Answer

There is a point a star's lifetime where it cools enough that it will collapse on itself. A black hole the mass of the Sun would only be 3 km in diameter.

See: http://www.school-for-champions.com/science/gravitation_escape_velocity_black_hole.htm

Although it is called a black hole because nothing is supposed to escape, not even light, particles and light does escape from its poles, due to its internal rotation.

Back to top


Relationship between dark matter and graviation?

Topic: Gravitation

Question

May 12, 2010

What is the relationship between dark matter and graviational force? ....Is dark energy the "reminent energy" from the big bang?

michael - USA

19714

Answer

The existence of dark matter is really speculation, as an effort to explain the motion of some stars. The motion could be caused by an extension of Relativity or by some of the laws of motion being different in various parts of the Universe.

The same is true of dark energy. It could be a form of anti-gravity, perhaps from dark matter, or it could be some other phenomenon.

The properties of matter and gravitational force seem to change with size and velocity. At the quantum level, there are certain rules. At the everyday level, Newton's laws hold. Then at the astronomical level and high velocities, relativity comes into play. Perhaps dark energy and dark matter are extensions at the extreme end, beyond relativity's influence.

Back to top


Who determined gravitation equation?

Topic: Gravitation

Question

March 9, 2010

PLEASE ADVISE,

WHO DETERMINED THE EQU F =GMm/RxR AND IN WHICH LABORATORY.

THANKS

PETER BECK

PETER - UK

19347

Answer

Isaac Newton formulated the equation F = GMm/R^2 in the UK in 1687. However, British scientist Robert Hooke claimed Newton got the equation from him.

They both were involved in the Royal Society. I don't think they have any formal names for their laboratories or if they even had labs.

Back to top


Does dark matter cause people to be negative?

Topic: Gravitation

Question

October 27, 2009

Is it because of the size of dark matter in the Universe that the way people think consciously is so negative.Does dark matter influance our ability to think and in which way.Is it dark matter in modern day that puts people under pressure.Is dark matter more advantages to modern human beings than cosmic light.Does cosmic light and dark matter work together.

Marius - RSA

18582

Answer

Dark matter is called that because it does not seem to give off light or reflect light. Since no scientists have seen it they call it "dark" matter.

But there seems to be some dark influence of people these days. Many seemed to be thinking so negatively, complaining above others, and just being plain mean. Some of it has to do with the fact that the news media emphasizes bad things. If you look around yourself, I think you'll see that most of the people that you know are actually very positive. It is like some cosmic light shining on them.

Back to top

Next 10


Summary

Hopefully, this reader feedback has helped provide information about Gravitation issues.


Learn from others


Resources and references

The following are some resources on this topic.

Websites

Gravitation Resources

Books

Top-rated books on Gravitation


Questions and comments

Do you have any questions, comments, or opinions on this subject? If so, send an email with your feedback. I will try to get back to you as soon as possible.

Feel free to establish a link from your website to pages in this site.


Where are you now?

School for Champions

Gravitation topics

Gravitation Feedback Comments




Gravity and Gravitation

Gravitation topics

Theories

Principles

Applications

Center of Mass

Orbital motion

Escape velocity

Gravity



Let's make the world a better place

Be the best that you can be.

Use your knowledge and skills to help others succeed.

Don't be wasteful; protect our environment.

You CAN influence the world.





Live Your Life as a Champion:

Take care of your health

Seek knowledge and gain skills

Do excellent work

Be valuable to others

Have utmost character

Be a Champion!



The School for Champions helps you become the type of person who can be called a Champion.