Mental Health Feedback
by Ron Kurtus
Readers have sent in a total of 23 comments and questions on Mental Health issues. They are listed according to date.
You can read them to further your understanding of the subject.
|Genetics vs. environment in mental illness||Brain||USA|
|Have had problems and am depressed||Depression Causes||India|
|Anxious, stressed and have breathing problem||General||USA|
|Can we catch the deepest thoughts?||General||India|
|Difference between Psychologist and Psychiatrist||Depression Basics||USA|
|No treatment for depression||Depression Basics||USA|
|What is mental health?||General||USA|
|Has violent temper||General||USA|
Genetics vs. environment in mental illness
April 28, 2012
Perhaps I overlooked something, but I am convinced that many forms of mental illness (of which I believe are many, and on a spectrum) are genetic. I did not see your opinion on genetics vs. environment. I suffer from degrees of bi-polar, OCD, depression and paranoia. I have had panic attacks for as long as I can remember - my first recollection of a panic attack was when I was 5. I simply could not explain it but I have been in psychiatric care for many years (I am now 48) and understand it better. My father also suffered from many of these ailments. He was also an alcoholic, and his father, grandfather and six of his brothers were alcoholics. I am a recovering alcoholic. Alcoholism is very prevalent in our family. Thank you.
Kathy - USA (22620)
Although some mental or emotional problems are purely genetic, while others are completely caused by a bad environment, most are a combination of the two, in different degrees.
Having many alcoholics in your family tree usually would mean that you are likely to be genetically susceptible to alcoholism. It is the way the body processes the alcohol, so it can be very much a genetic problem. However, if there is a family culture of heavy drinking, you might tend to feel that is the right way to act.
Likewise, with the other emotional problems, seeing family members with such problems can affect children, such that they imitate their elders.
Often psychiatric doctors use medication to deal with problems like panic attacks and depression. Although I am not a psychiatrist, I believe that it might be possible that you picked up some behavior traits from seeing family members act that way. Perhaps modeling people who don't have such maladies might help you overcome them.
Best wishes on having good mental health.
PS: I'll be adding material on genetics versus environment soon.
Have had problems and am depressed
October 11, 2008
1.i got bus accident on 03-12-1993 and injured right ear and 5days unconscious.really i dont know how the accident goes.my brother about accident after6th day i.e at the conscious stage.
2.i did one personal sin at the age of 33years.i.e i took marriage with
one prostitute.the result is so many irritations,ashamed,no carrier carrier improvement .i am giving details at the age of 41 years.now i am bachelor.i did b.tech(civil engineering)before 25 years.and i took pnuemonoctomy surgery at the age of 36 years.now i am waiting for carrier improvement and marriage.i am doing instructor job i.e to giving technical training to un employers from 2 years.
a)i cannot do duty actively
b)my staff cannot care about me
c)office store keeper gave a message to my id .he said i gt mentally
depressed and gave one mental clinic address.
i am waiting for your reply .please give your valuable suggestions.
please save my life.
baitapalle - India (16632)
Although you had some unfortunate experiences in the past, it is important to reflect on them as learning experiences. Do not think of them as tragedies. For example, you made a mistake in marrying the wrong person. Many people make such mistakes. Use that experience to use more judgment the next time you consider marriage. Do not dwell on your mistake or be ashamed of it.
Likewise for your accident and surgery. Be thankful and grateful that you survived them and are still alive. Count your blessings, because you are a lucky man.
Look after your health, by eating good food and getting sufficient exercise, which is important in reducing depression.
In your work, think in terms of how you can help the company and your fellow workers. Look outward instead of inward. this will make you feel better and will improve your career potential.
I hope these ideas will help you improve your life and your physical and mental health. And best wishes on finding a good wife. With the proper mental attitude, you should succeed.
Anxious, stressed and have breathing problem
June 23, 2008
Since November, after having a nervous breakdown, and not sleeping for a month, I've had dryness in my nose, and feeling as if no mucus is being produced, sometimes have a small, white, mucusy, stringy thing come out, but no boogers. I feel when I breathe in that the air goes straight into my lungs with no resistance, sometimes lungs burn. I have to use a saline gel to get some relief, but I want to breathe like i used to. Also I smell more intensely than before. I went to Ent dr, and he said my nose was dry and the turbinates were enlarged, and I have slightly deviated septum, but that should make me feel as if I have blockage instead of too much air going in. He told me to cont. the gel, and use Veramyst, if it doesnt work. Could I have damaged the lining of my turbinates somehow, I did have extreme anxiety, no sleep, and lots of xrays, because i kept thinking i was having a heart attack, could all that have contributed to my problem? i also had a bad respiratory inf. 2 yrs ago that I never went to dr for, it took 2 months to get over and went into bronchitis, where I coughed up tannish, green phlegm, but no odor or fever. I had fluid in my ears for a few months, but no infection, as I finally went and had ears checked after suffering through 2 episodes of vertigo. I exercise, have healthy diet, but I do take 1mg ativan to sleep @ night for past 2 months and have taken it on and off since November, I dont recall dry nose being a side effect of ativan though. Thanks,
Sheryl - USA (16130)
The first issue is to relieve your anxiety and stress to be able to sleep better. That is easier said than done. Worrying about your health certainly can contribute to your stress. But also, anxiety and lack of sleep can contribute to health problems. At the very least, when you are stressed, your body has lowered resistance and done not heal as well.
Take a look at your lifestyle. Although you exercise and eat a healthy diet, are you constantly in a rush? Do you dwell on your ailments more than your should?
Instead, try to slow down. Even walk slower. Push out negative thoughts and instead picture yourself as a healthy human being. Take 5 to 15 minutes a day to meditate or simply to sit silently, doing nothing without the or music. When you feel tense, take 8 to 10 slow, deep breaths. Slow breathing does wonders for reducing stress. Get a relaxing routine for falling asleep, with no television for at least 15 minutes before you go to sleep. Try to get off the sleeping pills, because they are habit forming.
As far as your health issues go, if you've had a physical and given a clean bill of health, there is no reason to think you will have a heart attack. Often pains in that area are a direct result of stress and indigestion. Learn to tell the difference between the symptoms of a heart attack and stress-related stomach problems.
Look at your environment to see if there is something in your house or place of work that could be causing an allergic reaction. Also check if you are allergic to such things as wheat. Sometimes people start to get reactions to common foods for some reason or another.
Hopefully, these ideas will help.
Can we catch the deepest thoughts?
March 29, 2008
myself suryakant bhosale ,supposed to be a chemical eng, would like to know whether we can catch the deeeeeeepest thought of the mind ,or the brain.
Suryakant - India (15622)
Recent studies have shown that high resolution fMRI brain scans are able to detect a person's thinking patterns and thoughts. Research is continuing in this field to get to the point of actually reading a person's mind.
Difference between Psychologist and Psychiatrist
July 9, 2007
What is the difference between a Psychologist and a Psychiatrist?
- USA (14044)
A psychologist treats behaviors, mental processes, emotional and personal matters. A psychologist may not prescribe medications, although they can work through a physician.
A psychiatrist must also be a medical doctor and can prescribe medications. It is a doctor who specializes in the diagnosis and treatment of mental disorders.
In most cases of depression, a psychologist can suggest treatment. In more severe cases, where there may be a medical condition, a psychiatrist is used.
No treatment for depression
October 5, 2006
there is no treatment
- USA (12075)
There are ways to relieve the problem, but not necessarily cure depression.
What is mental health?
May 18, 2004
What exactly is mental health? Spirtual?
Melissa - USA (3340)
Mental health mainly concerns the well-being of the mind and emotions. A person who in mentally unhealthy may have extreme fears or doubts, may be always depressed or have other symptoms beyond what a normal would have.
Spiritual health is very hard to define, but it is sort of a peace of mind about a person's spiritual nature.
Has violent temper
November 22, 2003
I wanted to ask,that y when i get mad i go crazy like i feel like grabing a knife and killing someone or hurting someone y is that.But sometimes when i hurt someone i feel that i didnt do it that somebody made me do it.How would i help my self on controling my actions.Because i was learning a little bit about yalls we site about mental health thats how i decided to read it because i new i needed some help,but please if yall have time to read this ill be happy.Because sometimes i cant control my actions because i cant think like a kid all i think of is war and i would wish i can think like a kid im bearly 13 years old.I hope yall would give me an answer about my question.Thank you
Enrique - USA (1346)
Some people get angry easier than others. And when those people get angry, they often can't control their emotions, such that they get too angry and do something violent.
It is like with a dog. You can tease some dogs, and they will growl at you. But others will quickly try to bite you. And some will even go out of control and try to kill you. Perhaps that type of dog has been teased too much.
With humans, some of having a temper is the nature of the person and some of it is upbringing. If there was a lot of violence in a person's upbringing, often he will have a quick and violent temper.
The thing is that you must learn to control and manage your temper. Otherwise you will do things you are sorry for and end up ruining your life. Every time you get angry, even just a little bit, kick yourself and say, "Don't do that. It's not worth it. Cool it."
You've got to remind yourself constantly to be cool and mellow and not let things bother you. The only person you should ever get mad at is yourself, if you're not doing as well as you should. If you learn to stay cool, you will be surprised how good things get. If someone hassles you or argues with you, figure that the person is just dumb and not worth losing your temper over.
I hope this gives you some ideas on handling your temper. Let me know how things turn out.
Questions and comments
Do you have any questions, comments, or opinions on this subject? If so, send an email with your feedback. I will try to get back to you as soon as possible.
Share this page
Click on a button to bookmark or share this page through Twitter, Facebook, email, or other services:
Students and researchers
The Web address of this page is:
Please include it as a link on your website or as a reference in your report, document, or thesis.
Where are you now?
Mental Health Feedback